Find the favorite they already return for and make it easier to get. A bakery could let regulars reserve a box of cinnamon rolls for Saturday pickup. Choose a perk you can deliver profitably. Customers get something they look forward to, and your business becomes part of their plans without relying on another coupon.
Offer first choice, a reservation or early access to something they already love. A salon might give regulars first choice of sought-after appointments; a class business might open booking early. State the terms and capacity clearly. Customers feel a real advantage, and you protect the value of what they already enjoy buying.
Look at what your best buyers repeatedly request, choose and get excited about. Ask which small improvement would make that favorite easier to enjoy. Check the cost and your ability to keep delivering it. You build around demand you can see instead of inventing a VIP label that changes nothing for the customer.